'Nothing Amiss', Maharashtra Tells SC on Judge Loya's Death

New Delhi:As senior counsel for the State of Maharashtra, Mukul Rohatgi appeared to have had his task cut out before the Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra, which resumed its hearing on Judge B.H. Loya's death on 12 February.
With the counsel for the petitioner and the interveners on the questionable circumstances surrounding Loya's death on December 1, 2014 in Nagpur having had their turn, it was expected that Rohatgi, whose opposition to the plea for an independent probe into Loya's death was already known, would seek to demolish their claims one by one.
However, Rohatgi, who was attorney general for the Narendra Modi government till he resigned last year, surprised everyone by spending the first half of Monday's hearing on the petitioners and the interveners "lack" of locus standi to seek an inquiry into Loya's death.
"Whose public interest" is involved here, he repeatedly asked, questioning the credentials of the petitioners. He alleged that the petitioners and the interveners had a private oblique motive in this case - to scandalise the judiciary by raising the issue after three years. "If they were genuinely concerned because Judge Loya was conducting a sensitive trial, then somebody would have done something?" he asked.
Normally the court, he said, does not entertain petitions merely based on newspaper articles and hearsay evidence. Primary evidence must be brought, he said. "All these petitions are based on the Caravan magazine's article. None of them, on their own, took any effort to approach the government. Instead, they have followed a cut-and-paste approach."
Rohatgi, however, agreed that the petitions need not be dismissed at the threshold on this ground, perhaps realising that it was too late in the day to raise the question of maintainability of these petitions.
"There is nothing amiss. The state is satisfied with the discreet inquiry that it ordered. Don't keep it hanging by further enquiry," he told the bench.
The Maharashtra Intelligence Department, during its discreet inquiry, had recorded the statements of four judges, after getting due permission from the chief justice of the Bombay high court. The judges were Shridhar Kulkarni, Shriram Madhusudan Modak, deputy registrar of Nagpur bench of the high court, Rupesh R. Rathi, and a local judge, Vijaykumar Barde. On Monday, Rohatgi referred to the statements of these four judges.
The only way to order an inquiry, is to reject the statements of the judges, who were with Judge Loya, till the ambulance carrying his dead body left Nagpur for Gategaon, his native place, Rohatgi said. "These judges who were with him like his shadow from November 29 have issued statements pointing out that his death was natural. Their statements have to be totally rejected, and they must be treated as conspirators in the crime (if the court were to order an inquiry)", Rohatgi contended.
During Monday's hearing, the three judges on the bench - CJI Dipak Misra, Justice A.M. Khanwilkar and Justice D.Y. Chandrachud - took an unusual break for ten minutes about 25 minutes after the hearing began. They left the court, and resumed the hearing again, surprising those present in the court room.
Despite agreeing that the petitions could not be dismissed at the threshold stage, Rohatgi went on to describe the petitioners as absolutely cavalier and reckless in their allegations.
Justifying the post-mortem done on Loya, even though it was a natural death, Rohatgi explained that had he died in the hospital, it would have been easy to give a death certificate. "If someone died on arrival, the hospital cannot give a death certificate. A post-mortem has to be necessarily undertaken for this purpose. No consent is required of the family by the hospital for the post-mortem", Rohatgi argued.
Accusing the petitioners of not doing their homework before filing their petitions, Rohatgi claimed that they relied on hearsay evidence presented by the media, and then moved the Supreme Court; their counsel argued on the basis of the material that the state government supplied, he added.
Rohatgi alleged that the petitioners' counsel argued the case like an appeal (from a lower court), and they did not bother to read pleadings. "It is for ulterior purposes, that it is going on," he said.
hen Rohatgi claimed that the pending petition, transferred from the Bombay high court to the Supreme Court, and filed by the Bombay Lawyers Association, had no explanation on why nothing happened during the past three years on the issue, the BLA's senior counsel, Dushyant Dave, retorted: "It is the Supreme Court which brought it here."
Rohatgi said that if the BLA was aware of the suspicious circumstances - including the transfer of Loya's predecessor, J.T. Utpat, who was conducting the Sohrabuddin Sheikh trial, in which BJP president Amit Shah was an accused - someone would have had the material to approach the court earlier. But only after Caravan published the story did the BLA become active. "Who is standing behind the petitioner?" he asked.
When Justice Khanwilkar queried Dave on this point, he said in a Public Interest Litigation, technicalities are not relevant.
Rohatgi argued that the statements of the judges on Judge Loya's death constitute unimpeachable evidence. All the statements are signed by the judges, there is no transcribing, Rohatgi averred. Their statements, Rohatgi claimed, have contemporaneous value, as the judges were with Loya all the time, before his death.
Reading a statement of one of the judges, Rohatgi referred to the doubts expressed by the petitioners' counsel over the judges' claim that three of them, including Loya, slept in one room at the VIP Guest House, Ravi Bhavan, in Nagpur, between November 30 and December 1, 2014, and said:
Arguing that "you can't make castles in the air", Rohatgi claimed he was trying to convince the conscience of the apex court, and that there is no semblance of doubt that Loya died in the car itself (while moving from Dande hospital to Meditrina hospital, Nagpur, where Loya was declared dead on arrival).
Rohatgi argued that natural discrepancies in the statements of witnesses underline the essential truth of a story. "If every statement of the witnesses says the same same thing, it is a ground for suspicion," he suggested. "The judges went to the paan shop, had Nagpur's unique paan. Loya answered nature's call. He had the presence of mind to call a local judge before collapsing", Rohatgi said, while narrating the sequence of events preceding Loya's death. Answering the question as to why and how an ECG was done on Loya at Dande hospital, where it was claimed he was first taken after he complained of chest pain, Rohatgi said: "These are natural contradictions. Judges are laymen insofar as medicine is concerned."(Courtesy thewire.in)
Source: Agencies


  
  

Comments


Shanebut says...
viagra generico venda no brasil generic viagra online without script can you get viagra cvs generic viagra viagra 40mg viagra pill can you take 2 100mg viagra viagra pills 100 mg generic viagra manufactured

BrettKix says...
cialis 10mg lasts best ed pills viagra online australia paypal erectile dysfunction pills preis viagra 100mg erectile dysfunction remedies cialis online romania erection pills generic cialis uk online pharmacy

StanleyIndem says...
buy viagra online in us best ed pills split viagra pills erectile dysfunction pills getting viagra in ireland erectile dysfunction pills discount vardenafil 20mg erectile dysfunction pills existe el generico de viagra

StanleyIndem says...
cialis 20mg efficace sex pills where can we get viagra in hyderabad ed pills is 25 mg viagra enough ed pills quanto custa o viagra de 50mg ed pills do i need a prescription to buy cialis in canada

SergioCooky says...
free pills viagra sex pills viagra online at boots ed pills where can you buy generic viagra best ed pills existe cialis 50 mg best ed pills price comparison levitra viagra cialis

BrianWax says...
cheap kamagra uk buy erectile dysfunction pills cialis 10 mg 4x erectile dysfunction remedies viagra sales at boots ed pills that work cialis 5mg vs 20mg erection pills order generic cialis canada

Arthurtic says...
safe website buy viagra viagra generic viagra vegetales generic viagra online order viagra europe viagra sale viagra generika deutschland kaufen viagra for sale uk viagra online kaufen ohne kreditkarte

RobertPef says...
cheapest source cialis cialis pills cialis super active cheap 200 cialis coupon cialis cheap canada cialis 5 mg buy cialis vancouver cialis rezeptfrei cheap cialis generic india

Jamesbeawl says...
cheap-cialis.net buy cialis online cialis online cheap cialis generic where to buy cialis no prescription tadalafil 20 mg buy cialis in europe cialis 20mg prix en pharmacie buy viagra and cialis online

Agustintof says...
viagra side effects mayo generic names for viagra generic viagra costs viagra price walmart pharmacy viagra commercial viagra commercial actress names pfizer manufacturer coupons for viagra viagra coupons 2016

GeorgeSnady says...
cialis buy online no prescription cialis online wholesale cialis cialis coupon how to buy cialis in japan buy generic cialis canadian pharmacy cheap cialis buy generic cialis cheapest viagra cialis levitra

Claudehor says...
generic viagra online paypal buy generic viagra order viagra from uk generic viagra online is viagra 25 mg enough viagra without doctor buy viagra in houston tx viagra online without script can you get viagra over the counter in uk

GeorgeAcete says...
how can i get my doctor to prescribe me viagra generic viagra without script herbal viagra online generic viagra 100mg can i buy viagra in the chemist viagra without doctor comprar viagra 25 mg viagra without doctor fda viagra generic

KeithNer says...
canada pharmacies online prescriptions aarp recommended canadian pharmacies online pharmacies legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies no prior prescription required pharmacy top rated online canadian pharmacies online pharmacy approved canadian online pharmacies lloyds pharmacy online uk

Robertgeolo says...
canada pharmacy approved canadian online pharmacies Legitimate Online Pharmacies legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies buy medication without an rx top rated online canadian pharmacies canada drugs canadian pharmacies online prescriptions northwest pharmacy canada

BobbyEmome says...
buy levitra cheap levitra cost per pill buy levitra philippines levitra coupon buy cialis viagra levitra

DavidLelay says...
discount viagra cialis levitra buy cialis online buy cialis canada buy cialis cialis discount program generic cialis 2018 cialis cheap buy generic cialis buy cialis shoppers drug mart

BobbyEmome says...
levitra prix discount cost of levitra generic levitra for sale brand name levitra online levitra buy online

Davidphalt says...
counter-strike adobe creative cloud download adobecc creative suite adobe create photoshop cs6 adobe reader free adobe photoshop cc 2017 adobe pro

Williedoomy says...
buy cialis online yahoo generic cialis online pharmacy buy viagra and cialis online generic cialis fake cialis pills cialis online pharmacy pills that look like cialis cialis online buy cialis in usa

ThomasHap says...
adobe account adobe creative creative curriculum adobe creative suite adobe flash player update photoshop cs6 adobe account adobe photoshop cs6 photoshop cs6 download

MatthewMup says...
cialis super active for sale generic cialis online pharmacy cialis viagra levitra sale generic cialis cialis buy online uk cialis online buy cialis genuine cialis buy cialis through paypal

Justinreupe says...
sildenafil 100 mg tablet viagra online how long do viagra pills take to work online viagra viagra cheap in canada buy generic viagra online best site for online viagra buy generic viagra comprar viagra cialis online

Francisslals says...
buy viagra today buy viagra daily viagra pill viagra online pills like viagra over the counter buy generic viagra sildenafil citrate 100 mg oral jelly generic viagra how to get rid of viagra spam

Leslieglymn says...
reliable source generic viagra viagra without prescription viagra pillen viagra without doctor online prescriptions viagra viagra without doctor get viagra for free viagra without a prescription buy viagra nsw

Charlesmic says...
viagra 100mg vs levitra 20 mg viagra online best online viagra site uk buy viagra generic levitra cialis viagra generic viagra online anyone use generic viagra generic viagra is generic viagra any good

LeslieWoort says...
acquisto sicuro viagra online buy viagra buy cheap viagra thailand viagra online bestil viagra online viagra without a doctor prescription sells generic viagra canada viagra without prescription online viagra purchase in india

Danielbodia says...
pill box viagra viagra without a doctor prescription generic viagra price compare viagra prices how to order viagra online viagra prices viagra us sales 2009 viagra prices cheap viagra generic 100mg

RichardTer says...
buy viagra from canada online viagra without a doctor prescription generic viagra sale online prescriptions online viagra sale lloyds pharmacy viagra without a doctor prescription buy viagra jellies online prescription order viagra australia

Jamesdor says...
forum buying viagra online online prescriptions cialis 20mg vs viagra 50 mg prescriptions online best online viagra viagra without a doctor prescription viagra tabletten 100 mg viagra prices much one viagra pill

Jamesdor says...
cheap viagra cialis uk viagra without a doctor prescription viagra 100 mg ou cialis 20mg viagra without a doctor prescription size pills does viagra come online prescriptions marcas de genericos de viagra viagra prices viagra pills new zealand

MichaelOverm says...
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa albuterol nebulizer list of approved canadian pharmacies ventolin inhaler Legitimate Canadian Mail Order Pharmacies levothyroxine medication online pharmacies that do not require a prescription levothyrox discount pharmacy

Michaelviact says...
farmaci generici cialis viagra viagra pills can i buy viagra legally online viagra fotos do generico do viagra buy generic viagra where to buy herbal viagra generic viagra online pharmacy best price viagra cialis levitra

RobertMaw says...
viagra cialis levitra buy online viagra pills viagra 100 mg posologia viagra online sildenafil citrate price cheap generic viagra sale viagra canada generic viagra online pharmacy cheapest viagra

Morgantok says...
viagra canada prednisone canadian pharmacies online prednisone 10 mg northwest pharmacy canada furosemide epharmacy lasix medication Online Pharmacies

RonaldClank says...
canadian online rx prednisolone Top Rated Online Canadian Pharmacies prednisolon Best Online International Pharmacies furosemida canadian pharmacies lasix medication drugstore online

Ronaldtus says...
order viagra sample viagra without a doctor's prescription order viagra now viagra without a doctor prescription order viagra in europe order viagra online cheap viagra new zealand viagra best place buy viagra online

Davidoxify says...
generic viagra cheap shipping viagra without a doctor prescription viagra 100mg generika viagra without a doctor's prescription viagra high street prices viagra online buy viagra hyderabad india viagra online can get viagra off shelf


Add Comment

Name:
Email:
Comment:

More Specials News


Junior Chidambaram wanted to order on Swiggy, Zomato while in CBI cust ..


Poor Muslim unable to gets burial place in Hyderabad ..

- 'Nothing Amiss', Maharashtra Tells SC on Judge Loya's Death
- Celebrate Telugu but don't ignore Urdu
- Goods Train derailment hit rail services
- Protesting Maharashtra doctors served ultimatum: resume duties or face suspensio
- Police keep strict vigil to prevent conduct of Jallikattu
- Bhopal encounter linked to the bogey of SIMI being raised in MP for long, says J
- Hyderabad police to keep tab on terror suspects
- Congress MLA Kista Reddy passes away
- Guidelines finalized for Recruitment, 6th paper on 'T' movement
- Skill building of DWCRA groups to generate economic activity: CM
- Has KCR family cleaned itself of its sins? Asks Ponnam
- Chinese Media criticizes Modi
- PUCL demands probe into encounters
-
-
-
-
-
-
-

Related News

Judge Loya death case: SC asks Maharashtra govt to give petitioners access to 'confidential' documents
Jan 16:The Supreme Court on Tuesday adjourned the hearing on two petitions seeking an independent probe into the death of CBI Spec .. read more
Judge Loya death case: SC takes over Bombay HC cases, bars HCs from entertaining related pleas
Jan 22:The Supreme Court on Monday ordered none of the high courts to hear petitions related to the death of Judge Loya while tran .. read more
No probe in Judge Loya's death, says SC; Cong says 'sad day in India's history' as BJP demands apology from Rahul Gandhi
April 19:The Supreme Court on Thursday dismissed petitions seeking an independent probe into the death of special CBI judge Brijmo .. read more
Come and debate with us who is right in law, SC Bench tells Katju
New Delhi, Oct 17:?In a historic first, the Supreme Court on Monday took judicial notice of a personal blog of a retired judge of .. read more
Jayalalithaa's death to be probed by commission headed by retired judge: Tamil Nadu CM
Aug 17:Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Edappadi K Palaniswami announced that a commission headed by a retired judge will investigate the .. read more

More Related News

- KCR requests Maharashtra to release water for Godavari Pushkaralu
- Egyptian court upholds death sentence against former president Morsi
- T-TDP to approach Supreme Court over irrigation projects
- Protesting Maharashtra doctors served ultimatum: resume duties or face suspension
- J&K Cabinet approves ordinance awarding death for rape of girl below 12 years
- Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Li'l Champs winners: Shreyan Bhattacharya, Anjali Gaikwad jointly lift the trophy
- KTR is having links with drug peddlers: Revanth
- Death for rape: Have you done any research before coming out with Ordinance, Delhi HC pulls up Centre

More Latest News:

- Congress' hands stained with blood of Muslims, says Salman Khurshid
- Trump administration toughens H1-B visa procedure
- Indian who went missing in Pakistan found at Facebook friend's home, to be sent back today
- Asaram Bapu rape case verdict: Centre asks three states to tighten security
- J&K Cabinet approves ordinance awarding death for rape of girl below 12 years
- Innovative hardware must be developed at T-Works: KTR
- Hyderabad's Mind Space Underpass ready for launch
- Altruista Health moves to new facility in Hyderabad
- Hyderabad Metro's TSavaari comes in handy for passengers
- UK-India cricket photo exhibition inaugurated at Salar Jung Museum
- Adilabad, a household name in Telangana for quality honey
- Finally, Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act in Telugu soon
- Three-day 'IT Handloom Mela' to begin on April 25 in Hyderabad
- Pre-recruitment training for constable aspirants begins in Hyderabad
- Awareness programme on TSPSC exam
- Laser-based saliva test to help diagnose diseases early
- Drinking water may boost mental skills in exercising elderly
- Fully support severe punishment to those who assault children: Anushka Sharma
- Sanju teaser: Ranbir Kapoor impresses as Sanjay Dutt
- FIFA subjects 2026 Morocco World Cup bid to fresh scrutiny
- India to play ICC World Cup 2019 opener against South Africa
- Shahzar Rizvi wins silver medal at ISSF World Cup
- Saudi Arabia's King Salman will patronize the launch of the Qiddiya Project
- Yemen army removes 300,000 Houthi landmines in liberated areas
- Iran warns Trump to remain in the nuclear deal or 'face severe consequences'
This page was created in 0.0208640098572 seconds